The Best Coffee Filter Substitutes

As a coffee enthusiast, I beg of you, please don’t think anything can be the best coffee filter substitute just because water can pass through it.

That’s not to say I don’t appreciate your predicament because I do. You probably walked into your kitchen with eyes half-mast, ready to brew a pot, only to realize you were out of filter paper… You have my real, true condolences; that is no way to start your day.

You know what’s even worse? Using socks or toilet paper to brew a cup. I just learned there is a legion of people out there who resort to such measures, some on purpose every day! You’re better than that, and you deserve a more refined coffee experience regardless of whether you have filters or not.

I’m here to tell you about a much better (cleaner, saner) way of brewing coffee both in an emergency scenario and introduce some sustainable eco-friendly alternatives to the almighty paper filter.

In a Pinch

For those reading this still in pajamas that need an immediate solution, I’ll give you the best options I found.

Paper Towel Filter

Some people when they are desperate for their morning brew use a paper towel as a substitute filter. You can either fold the towel and place it in the filter space hoping the grinds won’t find their way through, or you can fold it to mimic a #2 cone coffee filter like in this YouTube video:

 

Pros:  It’s easy to do, and you probably have paper towels on hand.

Cons: This method is a bit controversial with coffee purists. They claim the chemicals used in manufacturing the paper towels end up in the brew once the water passes through the towel.  Also, there’s a chance the paper towel will tear and break during the brewing process.

Verdict: Personally, I would use this method if I were in a bind, but would make sure the next time I had filters on hand.

Cheesecloth

Cheesecloth is a cotton cloth that resembles gauze and is used to separate solids from liquids (and vice versa). It comes in seven grades from extra-fine weave to open, depending on how many threads per inch in each direction of the cloth napkin. Cheesecloth is mostly used for, you guessed it, making cheese; but it comes in handy as a coffee filter as well.

The cloth filters work the same way as the paper towel method. Fold or cut it so it fits your coffee maker, and the water will pass through.

Pros: Versus the paper towel, it’s a stronger fabric and won’t tear during brewing.

Cons: Who has cheesecloth on hand? If you do, you may have to cut it and discard it after use.

Verdict: Use it if you have it, then stock up on filters.

A More Sustainable Solution

Running out of paper filters once might prompt you to find an eco-friendly alternative you can depend on long-term. There are better ways to brew! Here a couple of choices to consider:

Wire Mesh Filter

wire mesh coffee filter

Today many coffee makers come with a wire mesh filter which most consider the environmentally friendly option when compared to paper filters. They typically have a plastic rim that makes it easy to insert and remove, and the stainless steel wire mesh is simple to clean and maintain.

I use a wire mesh filter, and I like it because I never worry about whether I have any paper filters. After making a coffee pot, I empty the old grinds in the trash and wash them before the next use to make sure residual grinds don’t ruin my next cup. To be honest, I do miss the convenience of just throwing away the paper filter with the used grinds, but it only takes a minute to clean it and let it air dry.

If a mesh filter wasn’t included in your coffee maker, you can buy them individually and they come in a variety of sizes, shapes, and materials. They are relatively inexpensive, starting at just around $4.

A Fine Mesh Sieve

(Photo credit: Food 52)

For those that prefer pour-over methods, you can use a fine-mesh sieve to strain your coffee when you are out of paper filters.

For a steaming hot cup of coffee, place two tablespoons of grounds in the bottom or a glass measuring cup and add about a cup of hot water (not boiling water). Stir once and then wait five minutes for the coffee to steep, or in other words, for the water to take on the flavor of the coffee grinds. The longer you steep, the stronger the brew.

Once the time is up, pour the coffee through the mesh sieve into a coffee cup to separate the grinds from the liquid.

Pros: It can’t get much easier than this! This is coffee in its purest form. To extract the most flavor using this brewing method, grind your beans right before you brew. If you don’t have filters on hand, this is an easy solution.

Cons: Not everyone has a fine mesh sieve hanging out in a cupboard. Also, if your pre-ground coffee is too fine, it may escape through the sieve and end up at the bottom of your cup. If you grind your own though, you can set your grinder on a coarser setting to ensure the grinds don’t sneak through the sieve. That will help prevent a muddy cup of coffee.

Cowboy Coffee

For those who don’t want to try any of these options, consider brewing cowboy coffee. All you need is coffee, water, and a kettle to boil it. Heat the water, add the right amount of coffee, and bring it to a rolling boil. After it boils for three minutes, remove it from the heat and let it settle for a couple minutes. Then, pour a cup of cold water down the spout. This will settle the grinds to the bottom after a minute and then your coffee will be ready to pour.

Pros: This is another easy way to brew that I plan on trying next time I’m in a bind.

Cons: Although I’m sold on the theory, I will wait to see how well the grinds settle before I fully endorse this method. I’m not a fan of drinking grinds and avoid it at all costs. I’m pretty sure I speak for the masses on this one.

Verdict: I think it would be worth a try!

If you want to try the cowboy method too, check out this video first:

Just because you ran out of paper filters doesn’t mean you have run out of options for a hot cup of joe. Try one of these methods if you are in a pinch, and perhaps consider a more sustainable solution like a wire mesh filter or metal sieve to avoid running out of paper filters ever again. Either way, I hope you found this helpful and can enjoy your cup today, however unconventional it may be for you.

FAQs About Coffee Filter Substitutes

What to do if I run out of coffee filters?

Running out of coffee filters is definitely a possibility, but if you want to get your cup of fresh coffee, you can put one cup of coffee grinds in a cup and put boiling water in the cup. Let it settle for a few minutes and stir the coffee. At this point, you can have a decent cup of coffee to enjoy.

Can I use toilet paper as a substitute for a coffee filter?

Please don’t! Even though this might seem like a good idea, toilet paper usually comes with a scent that can definitely affect the flavor of your cup, also, the hot water can dissolve the paper, leaving grudges into your cup.

Are brown coffee filters better than white?

Brown coffee filters are made of unbleached paper and represent a better choice for your health and the environment in comparison to the white paper filters which are chemically bleached.

Further Read:

How to Find the Best Coffee Machine

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top