Updated with New Information On
Coffee is good. BPA, a chemical called Bisphenol A, is not. So, why would you want it in your coffee? If you and your friends are coffee lovers and you want a smooth, perfect cup of joe, then read the Best BPA free coffee makers explained in detail.
What is BPA and why should I avoid it?
BPA is an industrial chemical used in the production of plastic parts. When humans ingest it, it acts as an endocrine disruptor and has been implicated in a variety of health issues. I’m not going to get into that here, but you should know there is a greater chance of ingesting it if your coffee maker is not BPA plastic free.
Why? Because BPA is released when the hot liquid comes into contact with plastic. Since most coffee makers involve plastic in some way, this means that unless your machine is BPA-free, you could be drinking more than just beans and water.
If you don’t have one yet, no worries. I’ve found the best ones to recommend today. I picked four BPA-free coffee makers that online reviewers love that will brew a flavorful cup without any unwanted surprises. At the end, I’ll give you a cheat sheet to compare the different models.
Cuisinart DCC-3200 PerfecTemp Coffee Maker: $97
For those that like their coffee steaming hot, this is the BPA-free drip coffee maker is for you. It uses state-of-the-art technology to brew the hottest coffee possible without sacrificing the flavor of the coffee to fill its 14-cup glass carafe. The Cuisinart DCC-3200 is fully automatic and it’s brewing cycle may be set 24-hours in advance. Here are five key features:
- Brew strength control
- Self-clean option
- 1-4 cup setting
- Automatic shutoff
- Brew pause feature
PROS: Reviewers love the ability to control their cup of coffee with this maker both in brew strength and its temperature. It has a user-friendly control panel with one reviewer saying it’s so easy a child could figure it out. Like most Cuisinart models, it has a charcoal filtration system with replaceable pods that filters the water before brewing. Some reviewers believe the filtration system is why Cuisinart coffee always tastes so good. Because of its water filtration system, this can also be a decent tea maker as well as the water comes out quite hot.
“We’ve replaced an older Cuisinart DCC-1200 with this DCC-3200. Since it’s a popular line, I thought others might be interested in how they compare.”
Taste: Coffee in the 3200 is more flavorful. A new machine might be expected to be better, but I think they’ve gotten the flow and temperature of the brewing process better.
Temperature: The brewed coffee is much hotter. Both units have three temperature settings for the hot plate, but the settings on the 3200 are hotter.
Size and Capacity. The 3200 handles 14 cups compared to the 1200’s 12 cups. Yet as you can see from the photos, they are the same height to fit on a counter. They seem to get the extra capacity by making the 3200 a little deeper from front to back. We’ve been surprised at how useful the extra capacity is.
Carafe: The new glass carafe is just like the old one, only larger. It pours nicely with or without the lid on it. The new lid works the same as the old one, popping off and on. (I read some complaints about the lid on an intervening model with a spring opening, but if so, they fixed that by going back to the 1200 style).
CONS: The lid of the water tank doesn’t open far enough to use the coffee pot to fil it which frustrates some users. Others say the cord is too short which limits where you can place the machine. There is not a lot of negative feedback but some don’t appreciate the taste the coffee makes, or find the reservoir leaks at times.
Verdict: If you want a customizable cup, this BPA-free maker should be at the top of your list.
Hamilton Beach BrewStation: $35
This Hamilton Beach BrewStation is not your typical BPA-free coffee maker. It’s a 10-cup dispensing coffee maker that brews it all at once, but holds the coffee in a warming reservoir and dispenses it one cup at a time. Other features include:
- 1-4 cup and ice coffee option
- Automatic 2-hour shutoff
- Gentle warming heater to maintain temperature for 2 hours
- Convenient one-hand dispensing
- Interactive control panel that is user-friendly
PROS: This alternative to carafe-based machines is a good option for people that don’t want to rush their daily cup, or cups, of joe. Reviewers like that by eliminating the carafe there’s no chance of the coffee tasting burnt from sitting in glass on a hot plate for too long. People like the convenience of this system and don’t miss the mess that a carafe can sometimes make while pouring a cup.
CONS: The machine has a short plug, and some people claim it’s difficult to tell how much coffee is being poured into the cup. While there is no carafe to clean on a regular basis, you still must clean both the coffee and water reservoir and maintain the filter like any other machine which some people find cumbersome.
Verdict: This coffee maker is ideal for those that want coffee on demand without using a pod-based single-serve coffee system. If you don’t want to rush your daily cup(s), this machine is right for you.
Real User Reviews:
March 14, 2016
October 25, 2016
If you’re still unsure whether this kind of brewing system is right for you, check out this video that shows how the Hamilton Beach BrewStation works:
Bonavita BV1800SS 8-Cup Original Coffee Brewer: $107
The Bonavita BV 1800SS features a powerful 1400-watt heater that maintains a brewing temperature between 195-205 degrees. This BPA-free coffee maker comes with a thermal café to keep this steaming hot coffee warm for hours until you decide to turn it off, or the automatic shut-off does it for you. Other features include:
- One-touch operation
- Showerhead design for complete saturation
- Stainless steel lined thermal carafe
- Carafe lid, filter, and showerhead are dishwasher safe
- Compact, sleek design
PROS: People applaud the simplicity of this stainless coffee maker. They say the control panel is easy to use, it’s a breeze to clean, and the coffee tastes great. Many commented on the attractive design and are pleased this small coffee maker doesn’t dominate their countertop.
CONS: Some claim the carafe doesn’t keep the coffee steaming hot and believe it loses heat the longer it sits. They also advise not to use the carafe to fill the machine since it drips once you try to empty the water into the reservoir. Reviewers also wish it came with a brew pause feature to grab a cup before the seven minutes to brew an entire carafe is up.
Verdict: If you need a compact coffee maker and aren’t concerned about it being piping hot each time, this coffee maker might be the one for you.
Real User Reviews:
February 9, 2012
I’m really happy with this coffee maker, having chosen it over the Technivorm Moccamaster Coffee Brewer With Thermo Carafe – Technivorm 9587. It brews extremely quickly (about 7 minutes), and I measured the temperature of the water coming from the spout at about the 195F-200F range, so it’s in the right range for extracting optimum flavor — the brew from this machine is just at the point of being tip-of-the-tongue scalding. The water is dispensed at a number of different points into the filter, and looking at the grounds afterward you can tell that the dispersion pattern works well, as the coffee grounds remain clumped at the bottom of the filter, rather than being thinly spread across the entire filter.
Note that this is a minimalistic coffee maker. It is fairly compact, has an unassuming appearance, and there are no glowing dials, no HUDs, no clocks. There’s one control: the on/off switch. It has no timer. It doesn’t have a brew stopper, so you have to let the coffee maker finish before you can pour yourself a cup (since the coffee maker brews so quickly, this isn’t too big of a deal). You cannot navigate your kitchen at night by the light from this coffee maker, nor can you signal passing UFOs.
Nonetheless, it makes great coffee.
Melitta Gourmet Pour-Over Coffee Maker: $32
A pour-over brewing method makes it easy to customize your cup. The Melitta Gourmet 10-Cup Manual Coffee Maker uses a carafe and a plastic BPA-free cone to brew coffee using ground coffee and fresh, cool water. To brew, simply heat the water to below a boil, saturate the grinds using a swirling motion, agitate it slightly to eliminate clumps, and enjoy. The slower you pour, the bolder the taste of your brew.
PROS: People love the flavorful coffee that results from this brewing method. Many commented on how it is the ideal way to brew if you enjoy the taste of coffee because the steeping allows for maximum extraction of the flavors from the grinds. They also like it because it’s easy to use, clean, and store. Some reviewers say they purchased the Melitta to brew a decaffeinated option for guests, while others say they bought it because it’s small enough to store when it’s not in use, freeing up counter space. It’s also an ideal travel companion since it doesn’t require electricity and is small enough to throw in a bag.
CONS: Some think it’s too much work for their cup of joe. They would rather push a button on a programmed machine than heat water and pour. Regarding this model, some say it needs a window to view the brewing process to ensure the right amount of water is added. To be honest, it was hard to find negative comments about this model; out of 1,635 reviews, 73% gave it 5-stars.
Verdict: If you enjoy the taste of coffee, you need to at least try Melitta Gourmet Pour-Over Coffee Maker. I’m almost certain you’ll love it, but if you don’t, at least you’ll always have it on hand if you need it to brew a cup of decaf or need it when traveling.
Real User Reviews:
November 1, 2017
For those interested in learning more about the pour-over method, check out this video:
I hope you found this information helpful in finding your next BPA-free coffee maker. As promised, here is the cheat sheet to compare models:
|Brand||Price||Best feature||2nd Best||3rd Best||Dimensions||Amazon Ratings|
|Cuisinart DCC-3200||$97||Temperature control||Fully automatic||Brew strength control||10.1 x 16.4 x 10.8”||4.4/5 stars from 1,892 reviews|
|Hamilton Beach 10-Cup Coffee Maker BrewStation||$35||10 cups one cup at a time||Warming system||No carafe convenience||9.1 x 11.25 x 14.25”||4.2/5 stars from 3,605 reviews|
|Bonavita BV 1800SS||$107||Thermal carafe||Compact design||Powerful heater||6.25 x 10.75 x 12.25”||4.1/5 stars from 3,170 reviews|
|Melitta Pour-Over Brewer||$32||Customizable cup of coffee||Compact and simple||Authentic experience||6 x 8 x 9.8”||4.5/5 stars from 1,635 reviews|
BPA-Free Coffee Makers
Making coffee with this coffee maker usually takes from 5 to 8 minutes depending on how many cups of coffee you want.
You can definitely remove the carafe out of the machine, but have in mind that this should be done just before it starts dripping. This way your coffee will be strong.
No, not at all. With any coffee maker, you can make as much coffee as you want, even if it’s for just one cup or two per day.
Gordon is seriously addicted to coffee. He also likes to write. Match made in heaven? Yes. After years of boring casual coffee drinkers to death with bean origin stories, he took to writing publicly here at 2Caffeinated.